Roof Repair in Shelter Island, NY

Roof Repair in Shelter Island, NY

Straight answers and careful work on roof repair in Shelter Island, NY. Metal roofing is our specialty, but we do the whole roof.

Licensed & Insured 4.8-Star Rated 24/7 Available Shelter Island, NY
2,869+ Projects Completed
2,743+ Happy Customers
1,463+ 5-Star Reviews
24+ Years Experience

Roof Repair Services in Shelter Island

Roof repair is where we started in 2002 and it is still a good part of what we do around Shelter Island. We fix the actual problem rather than covering it, and we tell you plainly if a repair is only going to buy you a season.

When a Shelter Island homeowner calls us about roof repair, the first thing we do is come look. Somebody from the crew gets on the roof, checks the decking, flashing and fasteners, and works out what the job actually needs before a number is ever written down.

You get a written estimate for the roof repair on your Shelter Island home with the materials named and the price broken out, and that estimate is free. If we find something once the work starts, we stop, show you, and price it before we go any further.

Bronze metal roof and carport on a brick ranch home — Roof Repair work by our crew in Shelter Island

Our Roof Repair Process

What to expect once you call us out to look at your roof.

1

Find the Real Problem

Sometimes the answer is that the roof is fine and the trouble is a gutter or a vent. We will say so.

2

Tell You Straight

You hear whether this is a repair, one section, or genuinely the whole roof — and we would rather do the smaller job well.

3

Price It in Writing

Small repairs get a real price the same as big ones. We do not pad a small job to make it worth the trip out.

4

Make the Repair

The scrap goes with us and the yard gets picked up, even on a half day job.

Roof Repair FAQ — Shelter Island, NY

Straight answers, no sales talk.

Can my roof be repaired instead of replaced?

Often, yes. A good share of the Shelter Island roofs we are called to look at need flashing reworked, a valley resealed or a section refastened, not a whole new roof. We tell you plainly which one you have.

What does a roof repair cost in Shelter Island?

Small repairs on a Shelter Island home often run a few hundred dollars, and a larger section with flashing and decking work can reach a couple of thousand. We will not guess over the phone. We look, then we price it in writing.

How quickly can you get out to look?

Usually within a few days for Shelter Island homeowners, and faster when the roof is open and water is coming in. The look and the estimate are both free.

Will the repair be visible from the street?

We match materials as closely as weathering allows and blend the new work into the old, so on most Shelter Island houses you have to know where to look to find it.

What Our Customers Say

Our reputation is just the roofs behind us.

★★★★★

"Hail came through and they had photos and a written estimate to my adjuster in two days. Made the whole claim about as painless as it could be."

— Eric S.
★★★★★

"Thank you so much to the entire crew at Roofing Brothers for our amazing new tin roof! You were amazing to work with and I couldn't recommend you to others enough! Great communication, pricing, color options, efficiency, and HONESTY! If anyone needs a new roof, I highly recommend this crew! Phenomenal job."

— Kayla M.
★★★★☆

"Nice work on the roof and good communication throughout. I would have liked a little more warning about the dumpster arriving, but that is a small thing."

— Nadine H.

More Services in Shelter Island

Roof Repair in Nearby Cities

Roof Repair — Shelter Island Service Area

Need Roof Repair in Shelter Island?

Call us and we will come look. The estimate is free.

(877) 509-1137 — Free Estimate